Hadith 18

Al-Kashy, from Hamdawiya Bin Nuseyr, from Muhammad Bin Isa and Muhammad Bin Masoud, from Muhammad Bin Nuseyr, from Muhammad Bin Isa, from Saeed Bin Janah, from a number of our companions, and Al-Ubeydi said, ‘It is narrated to me as well from Ibn Abu Umeyr, ‘Ibn Abu Yafour and Moalla Bin Khuneys were at the river in the era of Abu Abdullah-asws. They differed regarding slaughters by the Jews. Moalla ate and Ibn Abu Yafour did not eat. When they came to Abu Abdulla-asws, they informed him-asws. He-asws was pleased with the deed of Ibn Abu Yafour and disapproved Al-Moalla in his having eaten it’’. [32]
Explanation: This is opposite to what is reported by Al-Mufeed and the Seyyid (see Hadeeth reference no. 7 above), and one of them is a suspicion (error) of the narrator, and in ‘Al-Kafi’ and in ‘Al-Tehzeeb’, in the previous narrators, there isn’t any mention of Moalla at the end of the Hadeeth, but in them, he-asws said: ‘Which one you is the one who refused (to eat)? ’ He said, ‘Me’. He-asws said: ‘You have done well’, so it does not negate this report.